Skip to main content

Consider the fans

In the 4th ODI played in Barbados yesterday England performed with ability that they had not previously shown any indication of possessing. The win was as convincing as their loss was complete in the 3rd ODI and it was surely fitting that it was their captain, Andrew Strauss, who played the important innings. More than just a chance to restore pride, this was no irrelevant victory since with this win England have now draw level in the series . This makes the 5th ODI in St. Lucia on Friday the decisive match.

Surely now the possible boycott of the 5th ODI cannot now happen as it would forfeit the match and give the series to England. Common sense should dictate that this match should go on unhindered but this would only be true if cricket is indeed the first priority. WIPA and the WICB have been down this road before and as everyone who had followed the game in the Caribbean knows, nothing can be ruled out as impossible.

If the West Indies had won the 4th ODI than they would have attained an unassailable 3-1 lead in the series, making the 5th ODI a meaningless match in terms of the determination of the trophy. The players would then have no issue in the boycott of the match since they would be able to prove their point after winning the series. This English win leaves the series open but may have opened the avenue for the possibility of WIPA making an even stronger statement.

If WIPA are really determined that the issues which they stand for are the priority then they should, in theory, remain prepared to boycott regardless of the state of the series. In fact they may even be in a stronger position to bargain now, as they can effectively control whether there will even be a contest for the series of if the trophy is handed to England without even an attempt to win it.

The points on which the WICB and WIPA differ have not changed. They are still in disputes over payment for previous tours, payment for player injuries and medical bills and retainer contracts. Either side insists that the other is to blame and the deadlock usually involves a court arbitration to resolve. The resolution of these issues have been time consuming in the past and nothing suggests that it will not be so again.

If the last ODI is indeed boycotted it will serve very little point other than to state WIPA are unwilling to back down, even for the sake of the series. It will also give the WICB ammunition to the argument that they are concerned more about the cricket and WIPA are concerned more about their own affairs. If WIPA state that they are going to boycott unless some resolution is made and none comes to fruition then the WICB risk looking as though they care more about maintaining their position than reaching an agreement.

If the match is boycotted, there will be no winner. The West Indian players will have lost the series. Both the WIPA and WICB will have lost credibility and their ability to represent and administrate respectively should be seriously called into question.

Most of all it is the fans who lose. West Indian fans have not had a lot to celebrate in the past years. The size of crowds as well as the energy of the fans show the importance of good results and how long the crowds have waited to see them. At this time, when fans should be given something to celebrate after years of faithful support it is unfortunate that off field matters should be given a priority. Whatever the result of the discussions between the WICB and WIPA , once cricket matches in the West Indies continue to be overshadowed by disputes , then it is only those who love the game that will suffer.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

best comedians of the decade

criteria : must do stand-up comedy. only judged from stand up and sketch . 10.Demetri Martin why: He likes constructing palindromes. That's reason enough. Uses all sorts of visual aids and sketches. Great with the one liners too. Most unconventional comedian since Gallagher.Maybe. 9. Russell Brand why: Obnoxious, loud and very strange. Known as much for his off stage antics than his comedy. But one of the best young 'angry' comedians out there. Although there's a sneaking suspicion the accent makes him cool (er). 8. Robin Williams why: Back in2002 with LIVE on Broadway, the show broke several records for a comedy show. Showed he's still funny, hasn't let success go to his head and can still make it all up on the spot. 7. Ricky Gervais why: In the Office for the first part of the century, everywhere else for the last. Most people know him for his film roles, but he's great on the stage too. Doesn't shy away from the controversial topics. And it isn't

Best Films of the Decade - 2010s - Third Part

11. Get Out (2017)-  Directed and written by  Jordan Peele. Horror seems to be an excellent medium to describe racism and it's somewhat amazing how obvious it seems in hindsight. One of the best debuts of a director in recent times, with a script that amps up the tension marvelously and serves up a twist in the tale that was impossible to see coming. Normally horror movies are seen as niche, but this film was popular with the wide audience and also at the award ceremonies further proving everyone was able to be captured by the film's quality. There has been talk of the film fitting into horror-comedy, probably due to Peele's comedy background, but while it is never laughably funny but does serve as a clever satire on the state of racial affairs. 12. The Death of Stalin (2017) - Directed by  Armando Iannuci.  Written by  Armando Iannuci, David Schneider and Ian Martin. Few topics are as ripe for satire as the workings of communist governments (provided one can

Best Films of the Decade - 2010s - Second Part

As always, a giant list. The first 10 can be pretty much interchangeable depending on my mood. 21.  John Wick (2014) - Directed by  Chad Stalehski . Written by  Derek Kolstad.   Keanu Reeves already had experience as the face of an action franchise but it's possible in the future that we remember more for John Wick than as Neo. A film that came out of almost nowhere and managed to simultaneously be a homage and a way forward for action movies. Building off of an extensive source of knowledge of the films of John Woo, Jean Pierre Melville, anime and spaghetti westerns, it's the closest anyone has come to replicating the Gun-Fu Hong Kong classics. The well crafted world of John Wick keeps expanding too, with even more additions to the series in the works. Long may it continue. 22.  Blade Runner 2049 (2017) - Directed by  Denis Villeneuve . Written by  Michael Green  and  Hampton Fancher.   A sequel to one of the most beloved and acclaimed sci-film films of