Skip to main content

Youth : scenes from a provincial life by J.M. Coetzee- A book review







Youth is a short novel, less than 200 pages. Yet the ability to convey in a few sentences what would take other writers paragraphs continues to be evident in J.M. Coetzee’s writing.

Youth tells a familiar story for people who live in the Commonwealth and what was even more widespread during the 1950’s and 1960’s when the story is set. It deals with migration and immigration. The narrator dreams of going to London to get away from his home country; when he gets there he will be able to live fully and truly be an artist.

The opening portion of the book is set in the University of Cape Town. The Sharpeville massacre, civil unrest and the possibility of a military draft finally give the narrator enough excuses to leave for London.

Just like the immigrant tales we are accustomed to, the gap between real London and fantasy London was too large to be bridged. The narrator takes a job as a computer programmer, which is monotonous but still he knows that must strive to become a poet. The alienation of the London populace keeps weighing him down after time. He cannot pass as an Englishman but deems it necessary to eliminate all ties with his homeland.

Youth has parts of the immigrant experience we are accustomed to reading about. The experience we find in books such as Selvon’s The Lonely Londoner’s and Naipaul’s The Mimic Men. The alienation and displacement are familiar themes of the immigrant experience but Coetzee’s narrator attempts to pass as an Englishman. This is an option that is impossible for the ethnic minority characters we are accustomed to. The different view of the immigrant experience is refreshing by the very familiarity it brings.

The narrator has ideas about poetry and love that rule his life. He expects that one must suffer for art and the ability to be able to create things of beauty. But there is one consolation: “''Because they are creators, artists possess the secret of love,'' and women, wanting to be brushed by ''the sacred fire,'' instinctively recognize this.”

Unfortunately for the narrator, absolutely nothing in his life happens according to his ideas. Youth speaks about that part of life when one has several dreams, all of them seemingly just out of reach. The period of life where frustration is all too regular.

While Youth is supposedly a story about a young man attempting to become a writer, the narrator never writes much. Given the semi-autobiographical nature of this novel, it seems that the narrator of the story and J.M. Coetzee have nothing in common as writers. Perhaps when J.M. Coetzee publishes a book about his life after 23 we will find out what made him such a great writer.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Oscar Predictions-Film Awards (i)

Best Director Most likely winner :     Steven Spielberg   for Lincoln. Leaving out Ben Affleck, Kathryn Bigelow and Quentin Tarantino pretty much made this Spielberg's to lose. And doesn't reflect too well on the Academy either. Backup Pick :    David O. Russell for  Silver Linings Playbook. The production company of Weinstein have been campaigning hard for this and it's a good film with the acting performances set up well. The thing about best director is it's the easiest award to give to someone the academy likes because it's ambiguous and the academy doesn't really love Russell. Most deserving :      Michel Haneke for  Amour. Haneke has the most carefully crafted film here. All in all it is definitely his film in every scene. His presence is all around the film and it is an excellent film. If they give it for the greatest impact a director has on the film, this is it. Best Adapted Screenplay Most li...

a list about plays (post 1950)

The general perception is good plays stopped being written. That all the plays being performed which remain popular are classics and there is no place for the playwright in the current dramatic world. The role of the playwright has been diminished but good plays have not become extinct in the 20th and 21st century.This list will attempt to reflect that by giving a selection of excellent plays written (and performed) after 1950. 20. Prelude to a Kiss- Craig Lucas. Premiered in California in 1988. Quick Description: Thought to be a metaphor for AIDS. A story about the switching of bodies between a new bride and an old man and how the husband must find the old man while keeping his love alive. Something of a Sci-fi style and one of the most original works in recent times. 19. Long Day's Journey Into Night - Eugene O'Neill.premiered in Stockholm at the Royal Dramatic theatre in 1956. quick summary: A play about addiction and how it affects everyone around the addict.The characters ...

Travel Writings- Rome (I)

Rome is a cliché. Usually that isn’t a good thing but when the cliché is that a city is cool, full of life and gorgeous, the clichés can stay. Rome is possibly the only European capital that can claim to rival Paris in the popular imagination in terms of having an expectation around it. Even Paris is now succumbing to parallel narratives due to the sheer size of the city (much like London), with the immigrant experience less of an unknown story (to non-immigrants anyway. Immigrants always knew it wasn’t cities paved with gold they’d find). Some combination of smaller population, less immigration and the weight of centuries of civilization being still visible across the city has allowed Rome to actually deserve the tag of “The Eternal City”.   My idea of Rome comes to me primarily from Italian films of the 1960s. Rome is black and white in my mind just as it is on Fellini’s film reel. I had low expectations. Months in London had allowed cynicism to set in...